Hy Hy Hy......Merry New Year! Before We Leave You!...Why Not, Let's All Enjoy The New Year With The "World's Greatest Key Lime Pie" Baked By My Good Friend in North Carolina,
"Kutchie Pelaez". Kutchie's World Famous Key Lime Pie Will Give You A Pucker as Well as Put a
Huge Smile On Your Face! Contact Kutchie Pelaez at Kutchie's Key West Kutcharitaville Cafe
just South of Asheville, NC. and Let Kutchie Put A Big Smile On Your Face as His Pie Does
Mine! What A Great Way To Start The New Year!!!

Thanks and God Bless,................................................Stuart Varney

yay for smartones! I was hoping it'd win since its the least harmful to my diet, definitely picking it up next time i'm at the grocery.

I choose them all because pie is calling me, calling me, calling me.

I like pie! I raised my hand when you said who likes key lime pie, I love that stuff. The best key lime pie I have ever had was at some restaurant...in the Florida Keys of course.

I'm sick of companies charging more for 'healthy' products that are really the same product but a lot smaller. Of course it's going to be healthier, it's half the size! If you only had half a slice of pie it would be half the fat wouldn't it lol. I'm really enjoying being a real member of you site, I'm such a huge fan, but now I have to find something else to pass my time with because I've watched and read all your stuff. Admittedly I avoided most of the User Submitted Reviews, but other than that I've seen everything. Awesome review, you should have done the new Ben & Jerry's Key Lime Pie Ice Cream I believe they've released in the USA. I'm picky with pie, but I do love a lovely Apple Pie!
Keep it up FFM!

To be honest, when I first heard that this would be "Pie Week", my first thought was "ugh... I *hate* pie!" However, on second thought, this isn't entirely true... in fact, I hate pie *crust* (too greasy; not much taste besides the grease), and my hatred of the crust is surpassed a thousand times over by my hatred of whipped cream. Therefore... I'm the bizarre individual who devours the fruit filling in a fruit pie and leaves the crust behind, and who scrapes the whipped cream off of a cream pie and then happily eats only the creamy custard-like filling, and again, leaves the crust behind. So... I know, this is blasphemy to all of the true pie lovers out there, but the only part of a pie that I enjoy is the filling.

That said, when it comes to that filling, I *do* love me some key lime pie (okay, okay, the *filling* of key lime pie, meaning the actual lime custard, minus the crust and the whipped cream... get that nasty stuff AWAY from my key lime goodness)... and I agree that the "WTF" is crucial to the greatness of a key lime pie. Best of all is when the slice of pie comes with an actual lime wedge on top, rather than just a piece of lime peel; one can then eat the lime wedge along with the pie in order to really amp up the WTF! I don't know if I should be ashamed to admit this or not, but the best key lime pie I ever tasted was at Disneyland, several years ago... I don't even remember the name of the restaurant, unfortunately, but it was in New Orleans Square... this pie had an *amazing* level of WTF, but the custard was also creamy enough to avoid being *too* sour (although it would be too sour for those who do not believe in the WTF).

I'm impressed that the Smart Ones pie came out on top in this frodown... I will definitely be trying this one! Not too much crust, and good WTF... and somewhat healthy, too!... sounds like the formula for a great key lime pie experience! I'm surprised that the Sara Lee pie fared so poorly; they usually manage to make pies that are quite good, as far as frozen pies go... usually, Sara Lee beats Edward's (or the nastiness that is Marie Callender's) pies any day. However, it sounds like this particular Sara Lee pie is one to avoid.

Loved the frodown! As previously stated, I'll have to try the Smart Ones pie soon.

So what's *your* favorite key lime pie? Or even your favorite pie in general?

i'm wondering if you taking a bite of the sarah lee on the edge where the whipped cream is somehow affected your opinion

thanks for the entertaining review

i live in south florida, i'm not into key lime pies

Loved this! great review.
"...Cuz, I wanna eat more." hahaha, i so completely understand....I don't know how you didn't polish off all the pies at once. I'm a sucker for frozen desserts.
I really want some key lime pie now. I actally dont like pie that much, but soft pies ae awesome. Lemon meringue, key lime, pumpkin.....awesome.
My best key lime pie? Mom's, of course! Fresh key limes and everything. yum.

Awesome! I do like the top two contenders, but the WW gets extra brownie points for healthiness. Perfect summer pie. I had a really good key lime pie somewhere, but it was so long ago, I can't remember where :( Maybe, just maybe , it was at Joe's Crab shack, but not positive.